In Commonwealth v. Eldred, an underreported July 16 case with nationwide implications, where addiction was an underlying issue in a criminal case, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled that it was not cruel and unusual punishment to put a person who is on probation in jail after one positive test for drugs.
Less than two weeks after a court ordered Julie Eldred to not use drugs while on probation, she tested positive for the opioid fentanyl. Consequently, Ms. Eldred, a chronic substance abuser, spent about 10 days in jail until an inpatient treatment bed was available.
In the subsequent appeal, Lisa Newman-Polk, Ms. Eldred’s attorney, argued that incarceration was unconstitutional cruel and unusual punishment because Ms. Eldred’s substance abuse disorder made her incapable of remaining drug free.
Newman-Polk, a certified social worker with clinical experience treating addiction, called the decision a “massive blow” that would place the court “on the wrong side of history.”
The court did not agree. Nor do I. To the contrary, adoption of Miss Eldred’s disease theory would dangerously undermine America’s efforts to combat its metastasizing opioid epidemic, almost certainly lead to increased drug related deaths, increased risks to public safety, increased recidivism, longer prison sentences for addicts without the possibility of probation or parole, fewer options like drug courts to incentivize recovery, and millions of new dollars invested in unproven community drug treatment programs.
Most important, it would remove an addict’s personal responsibility in the recovery process, the sine qua non of successful recovery.
According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, substance abuse disorder (SUD) occurs when a person’s use of drugs or alcohol leads to health issues or problems at work, school, or home. Relapse is often a part of the recovery process.
But not everyone agrees with the disease model.
The court cited the Commonwealth’s behavioral model which postulates that SUD may affect an individual's urge to use substances, but it does not render that individual without the free will to use substances.
The majority ultimately concluded that the defendant's claim of SUD rested “on science that is not tested.”
Justice David J. Lowry, writing for the majority, emphasized that a defendant who violates probation is not being punished for the violation (drug use), but “anew on his [or her] underlying conviction.” The court recognized that “addiction is a status that may not be criminalized.”
Continuing, the requirement of remaining drug free is not, as Ms. Eldred contends, “an outdated moral judgment about an individual's addiction. Rather…. the requirement is based on the (sentencing) judge's consideration of the defendant's circumstances and that she committed the underlying crime to support her drug use.”
Having worked with many addicts for many years, I can attest that many former users credit a stint in jail (or the mere threat) for jump starting their recovery.
Justice Lowry’s well-reasoned opinion will help protect defendants by giving them clear motivation to remain substance-free while providing for the protection of the public.
Ironically, should she remain clean and sober, Ms. Eldred may one day thank the sentencing judge for saving her life.
This article was written by a friend of the Urchin who practices law, and has a long-term interest in the legal and scientific study and treatment of substance abusers and substance abuse issues. He is a regular contributor to articles pertaining to these topics.
With Love,
The Recovering Urchin
Sign up for our newsletter
-
April 2019
- Apr 5, 2019 I Think My Spouse Has A Drinking Problem Apr 5, 2019
-
December 2018
- Dec 13, 2018 The Ant and the Grasshopper Dec 13, 2018
- Dec 3, 2018 Where I Go For Hope Dec 3, 2018
-
November 2018
- Nov 23, 2018 This I Believe Nov 23, 2018
- Nov 12, 2018 Guest post: Grace, compassion and the stink of the soul -- part one Nov 12, 2018
- Nov 7, 2018 The Importance of Home Groups Nov 7, 2018
- Nov 5, 2018 The Law of Averages Nov 5, 2018
- Nov 1, 2018 Guest post: A List Of Stupid Things That Mess Up Recovery Nov 1, 2018
-
October 2018
- Oct 29, 2018 Guest post: Grace within Oct 29, 2018
- Oct 28, 2018 Guest post: My ugly, unvarnished truth Oct 28, 2018
- Oct 27, 2018 Staying Sober in Dark Times Oct 27, 2018
- Oct 24, 2018 I Am Responsible Oct 24, 2018
- Oct 23, 2018 The Opioid Epidemic Oct 23, 2018
- Oct 21, 2018 The Challenge of Being an Introvert in Alcoholics Anonymous Oct 21, 2018
- Oct 20, 2018 Physical Pain And Spiritual Pain Oct 20, 2018
- Oct 18, 2018 My 38th Street Bridge Blackout Oct 18, 2018
- Oct 10, 2018 Who are you? Oct 10, 2018
- Oct 9, 2018 Guest post: Zen Spot #155 — Mindfulness, meditation and letting sleeping dogs lie Oct 9, 2018
- Oct 8, 2018 The Taping Pit Oct 8, 2018
- Oct 7, 2018 The Lou Gehrig of Recovery Oct 7, 2018
- Oct 6, 2018 Guest post: Zen Spot #161 — Mindfulness, meditation, the Beastie Boys, potato salad, the number 12 and a phone call from a Buddhist monk Oct 6, 2018
- Oct 6, 2018 The Cathedral of Chartres Oct 6, 2018
- Oct 5, 2018 Guest post: Addiction and spirituality Oct 5, 2018
- Oct 4, 2018 Meetings When I Travel Oct 4, 2018
- Oct 3, 2018 Why Discipline Matters Oct 3, 2018
- Oct 2, 2018 Meditations on Anonymity Oct 2, 2018
- Oct 1, 2018 Guest post: Zen Spot #36 — Mindfulness, meditation, autopilot and the internal gyroscope Oct 1, 2018
- Oct 1, 2018 This Is Our Plague Oct 1, 2018
-
September 2018
- Sep 29, 2018 Guest post: Zen Spot #143— Mindfulness, meditation and the intersection of Broad and Vine Sep 29, 2018
- Sep 29, 2018 Seven Things My Sponsor Suggested Sep 29, 2018
- Sep 27, 2018 Guest post: The Opioid Crisis—Personal Responsibility, Choice, and the Law Sep 27, 2018
- Sep 24, 2018 Page 87 Sep 24, 2018
- Sep 20, 2018 Humility Sep 20, 2018
- Sep 17, 2018 Honesty Sep 17, 2018
- Sep 10, 2018 The Purity of the Message Sep 10, 2018
- Sep 3, 2018 Recovery Resources Sep 3, 2018
-
August 2018
- Aug 28, 2018 What’s The Problem?! Aug 28, 2018
- Aug 17, 2018 Roll Call Aug 17, 2018
- Aug 17, 2018 I Don’t Know Aug 17, 2018
- Aug 17, 2018 I Need Help Aug 17, 2018
- Aug 17, 2018 I Was Wrong Aug 17, 2018
-
July 2018
- Jul 8, 2018 Welcome to The Recovering Urchin! Jul 8, 2018
- Jul 8, 2018 The Most Important Thing Jul 8, 2018
- Jul 7, 2018 Role Models Jul 7, 2018